Trip to Harbour Island, Bahamas

Nestled off the northeast coast of Eleuthera, Harbour Island is a jewel of the Caribbean renowned for its iconic pink sands, picturesque pastel buildings, and inviting laid-back atmosphere. Home to around 2,000 residents, this small Bahamian paradise blends colonial history with the warmth of modern island culture. Once governed by British Loyalists, Harbour Island’s heart—Dunmore Town—exudes heritage in every facade and alleyway. Over recent years, it has become a coveted escape for travelers seeking both sophistication and authenticity, drawing in visitors with its thriving local cuisine, lively art scene, and renowned hospitality.

With its compact 3.5-mile-long, 1.5-mile-wide terrain, Harbour Island (often misspelled as “harbor island bahamas” or “harbor.island bahamas” in international travel searches) is easily explored by foot or golf cart. Pink Sand Beach, one of the world’s rarest natural wonders, runs along the entire eastern shoreline, drawing global acclaim. The island’s coral reefs, boutique resorts, and strong emphasis on community stewardship and environmental conservation reflect both its allure and its responsibility as a Caribbean treasure.

Here’s a detailed, updated 7-day itinerary designed to blend culture, relaxation, and adventure—perfect for those ready to explore Harbour Island’s unique character and uncover the magic of this enchanting destination.

Day 1: Arrival and Settling In

After landing at North Eleuthera Airport, catch a taxi (approximately B$5-10 per person, subject to season) for the brief 5-minute ride to the Three Island Dock, the main jump-off point for Harbour Island. Water taxis run every 15 minutes between 7 am and 6 pm, with a scenic ride across harbor bay bahamas for B$6 per person. Watch for dazzling turquoise waters and the gentle approach to Dunmore Town’s serene waterfront as you arrive.

Check in to the Pink Sands Resort, famed for its charming pastel buildings and lush, flower-filled paths. If you prefer a more contemporary boutique experience, other excellent options include Coral Sands Hotel, with its oceanfront pool and garden, or The Dunmore, admired for its elegant coastal décor and expansive verandas. After refreshing from your travels, stroll along the water’s edge, taking in your first glimpse of the pink-hued sands. Most resorts offer complimentary bicycles or golf carts—ideal for orienting yourself and exploring the island at your own pace.

In the early evening, wander down Bay Street. Sip a tropical cocktail—Bahama Mama or Goombay Smash—at Rock House’s open-air terrace, overlooking the harbor. For dinner, sample Bahamian specialties such as conch salad or grilled snapper at Queen Conch, a beloved local eatery with waterfront tables.

Day 2: Historic Dunmore Town and Island Shopping

Begin your morning with an island-style breakfast at Arthur’s Bakery, recently renovated and still the go-to for fresh-out-the-oven cinnamon rolls and locally roasted coffee. Its shaded verandah is a favorite with both islanders and visitors.

Dedicate the morning to discovering the heart of Harbour Island—Dunmore Town. Established in the late 18th century as a Loyalist settlement, the town stands today as a vibrant showcase of Caribbean-colonial architecture: weathered wooden cottages with candy-colored hues, traditional louvered shutters, and flowering bougainvillea climbing up the walls. Pick up a self-guided historic walking map from the Dunmore Town Council office or join a guided golf cart tour—drivers are filled with insider stories about the island’s old churches, the original settlement wells, and the history of the Loyalist movement in the Bahamas.

Make time to duck into the Haynes Library, the island’s cherished pink-and-white colonial-era jewel dating from 1897, which often hosts community events and features an excellent Bahamian history section.

Shopping here is a pleasure, with locally owned boutiques like Blue Rooster and A&A Hidden Treasures offering handmade straw bags, art, and island-inspired fashions. Civic pride in craftsmanship means you’ll find plenty of authentic souvenirs and original artwork—not just trinkets for tourists.

For lunch, enjoy fresh grilled lobster rolls at Angela’s Starfish Restaurant, popular for its ocean breezes and vibrant murals. Take the afternoon to relax, or continue exploring by golf cart: the island’s compact size keeps everything within leisurely reach.

Day 3: Pink Sands Beach and Natural Wonders

Start early with a sunrise walk on the renowned Pink Sands Beach, stretching nearly three miles along the Atlantic shore. The signature pink hue is the result of microscopic red foraminifera—a marine organism—blending with white sand, a rare phenomenon found in just a handful of locations worldwide. The calm, shallow water makes it an unbeatable spot for morning swimming, shell collecting, and photography.

Stretch your adventure by meandering north towards the less visited segments of the shore, particularly at the edge of Ramora Bay. On clear mornings, it’s common to spot locals leading horseback rides along the water—consider booking an hour of horseback riding to experience the beach’s beauty from a unique vantage point.

Later, rent paddleboards or kayaks from Bahamas Outdoor Adventures, whose guided coastal eco-tours explore the mangroves and coves along the island’s western side. Staff provide excellent insights into native flora and fauna as you navigate through clear waters teeming with sea turtles and tropical fish.

Cap your afternoon by visiting the Lone Tree, an atmospheric driftwood sculpture that has become one of Harbour Island’s most iconic photo subjects. The tree rests on the sand flats just off Bay Street and appears especially dramatic at low tide.

Dinner at The Landing, set in a historic 19th-century property, offers Caribbean-fusion dishes using sustainable, locally sourced ingredients. Their fire-roasted conch and mango chutney is legendary.

Day 4: Coral Reefs and Marine Wildlife

Harbour Island’s coral reefs are considered among the healthiest in the region, making them a world-class snorkeling and scuba destination. Book a half-day trip with Valentine’s Dive Center, which runs daily excursions to nearby reefs teeming with parrotfish, angelfish, rays, and—if you’re lucky—a gentle nurse shark or two. Guides provide all necessary equipment and safety briefings. Expect to pay around B$100-150 per person for a dive or snorkel tour; always reserve in advance during peak months (December-April).

If you are more comfortable above water, opt for a glass-bottom kayak rental or join Bahamas Catamaran Charters for a daytime cruise through the crystalline shallows, pausing at hidden coves to swim and spot starfish.

For lunch, enjoy a picnic on the sand, arranged by your hotel or the friendly staff at the Gourmet Market on Dunmore Street. Afternoon relaxation at the Pink Sands Resort spa provides the perfect wind-down: signature treatments here often incorporate locally harvested coconut oil and native botanicals.

As dusk approaches, book a sunset cruise for a memorable panorama across bar harbor bahamas and Eleuthera’s rugged coastline. Bring your camera—twilight here paints the sky in hues as remarkable as the sand itself.

Day 5: Eleuthera Escape and French Leave Beach

Venture off-island with a short water taxi (B$15 per person roundtrip) to Governor’s Harbour, the historic seat of Eleuthera. Here, spend your morning at French Leave Beach—a rarely crowded expanse of dazzling white sand and translucent waters. Recognized by travel publications in recent years as one of the Caribbean’s most unspoiled beaches, French Leave offers gentle surf ideal for families, as well as paddleboard and kayak rentals if you want to explore the shore.

If you’d like to delve into Bahamian history, stroll up to the 19th-century Haynes Library and visit the historic Anglican church—the “pink church”—that overlooks the harbor.

Have lunch at Buccaneer Club, a cheerful local eatery famed for its coconut fried fish and tropical fruit platters (most mains B$15-20). Afterwards, swing back to Harbour Island in time for a leisurely stroll through Princess Street Gallery, the leading venue for local Bahamian artists.

In the evening, join locals at the Gusty’s Bar—open-air, lively, and perfectly unpretentious—the place for fresh conch fritters, cold Kalik beer, and live rake-and-scrape music on weekends.

Day 6: Cultural Immersion and Local Cuisine

Begin your day with breakfast at the Coral Sands Hotel’s Beach Bar, known for its sweeping ocean views and breezy terrace. Try a local favorite such as johnnycake (Bahamian cornmeal bread) with guava jam.

Next, embark on the Dunmore Town Historic Walking Tour, which delves into the island’s colonial roots, the era of the Loyalists, and the pivotal role of the Bahama Harbor island in regional maritime history. Many guides—often lifelong residents—will share stories passed down through generations, adding a treasured personal touch.

By late morning, explore local art galleries such as Princess Street Gallery or the Briland Art Shack. Here, you’ll find contemporary paintings, driftwood sculptures, and crafts reflecting island themes, much of it available for purchase.

For lunch, try Sip Sip—a breezy, open-air café on the Pink Sands Beach adored by locals and visitors for fresh conch chili, lobster quesadillas, and homemade ginger-lime coolers. The relaxed dining experience is nearly as memorable as the food.

Dedicate the afternoon to exploring local customs: pop by Fisherman’s Dock to watch the daily catch arrive, or take a Bahamian cooking class if available (Pink Sands Resort and various private chefs occasionally offer group lessons; inquire ahead). If you’d rather relax, many visitors enjoy unwinding amid Coral Sands’ lush Beach Garden, brimming with tropical flowers, palms, and the gentle soundtrack of the waves.

Reserve dinner at The Dunmore—enjoying oceanfront seating with a menu that blends Bahamian flavors with international flair. Their grilled spiny lobster and white chocolate bread pudding are island classics.

Day 7: Farewell and Departure

After a final sunrise stroll or swim on Pink Sands Beach, linger over breakfast at Malcolm 51, a stylish bistro inside The Dunmore, lauded for its pastries and Bahamian-spiced eggs.

Check out from your accommodation and, with a final look over Bay Street’s bustling waters and pastel facades, catch the water taxi back to North Eleuthera. Take with you a memory of mornings tinged in pink, the laughter and music of Dunmore Town, and the warmth of an island that truly lives up to its legend.

Safe travels—until your next visit to Harbour Island, the Bahamas.

Places Mentioned

• Pink Sands Resort
• Coral Sands Hotel
• The Dunmore
• Rock House
• Arthur’s Bakery
• Dunmore Town
• Haynes Library
• Blue Rooster
• A&A Hidden Treasures
• Queen Conch
• Angela’s Starfish Restaurant
• Bahamas Outdoor Adventures
• Lone Tree
• The Landing
• Valentine’s Dive Center
• Bahamas Catamaran Charters
• Gourmet Market
• French Leave Beach
• Princess Street Gallery
• Buccaneer Club
• Gusty’s Bar
• Coral Sands Hotel Beach Bar
• Briland Art Shack
• Fisherman’s Dock
• Sip Sip
• Malcolm 51